The Giving Gap: Black-Serving Nonprofits Received Less Than 1% of American Charitable Dollars

Black-serving groups got 0.61% of US charitable giving in 2022. Ahead of Giving Tuesday, leaders explain what the gap costs.
Nonprofit

Organizations that serve Black communities received $3.3 billion in 2022, just 0.61% of all charitable giving in the United States, according to the Lilly Family School of Philanthropy at Indiana University.

The figure comes from the school’s Communities of Color Index, which tracked giving from 2012 to 2022. Across that decade, organizations serving all communities of color never received more than 3% of total giving.

The numbers land as Americans prepare for Giving Tuesday on December 1, one of the biggest fundraising days of the year.

The gap shows up inside the organizations too. Research by the Bridgespan Group and Echoing Green has found that Black-led nonprofits bring in about 24% less revenue on average than white-led peers.

The Giving Gap, an organization founded in 2020 to connect donors with Black-led nonprofits, surveyed 168 leaders of Black-founded organizations for its 2024 State of Black Nonprofits report. Ninety-seven percent said they needed support for general operations, the flexible money that pays staff and keeps the lights on. Sixty-two percent said they faced personal financial strain and had to seek outside income.

Part of the problem is visibility. The IRS Form 990, the main source of nonprofit financial data, does not ask about the race of an organization’s leaders, which makes the gap harder to measure and easier to ignore.

Giving Gap CEO Heather Infantry told theGrio that Black-led groups are often offered “technical assistance in lieu of dollars because it’s believed that we can’t be good stewards of money.”

Relationships drive much of the rest. Donors tend to fund people they already know, and many Black-led organizations sit outside the networks that steer major gifts.

Those organizations include the mentorship programs, fatherhood initiatives and youth leagues that Black men run in their own neighborhoods.

For donors, the research points to a few concrete moves: give unrestricted dollars, commit for more than one year, and look past the largest names to the local groups doing the work.

For now, the data says the gap is wide and stubborn. Giving Tuesday is one day, but it is a useful place to start closing it.