‘Reasonable Doubt’ Creator Raamla Mohamed Hunter Says Black Creators ‘Shouldn’t Have to Speak for the Whole Black Race’

Reasonable Doubt creator Raamla Mohamed Hunter says Black creators shouldn’t have to speak for the whole race at an AAFCA screening.
Reasonable Doubt 3

Raamla Mohamed Hunter isn’t making Reasonable Doubt to represent every Black viewer. She’s making the show she wants to watch.

“I feel like as Black creators, we shouldn’t have to speak for the whole Black race,” the creator and showrunner said during a screening of the Hulu legal drama in Los Angeles on Wednesday night. “White people don’t have to speak for all the white people. I create a show because I want to watch what I want to see, and if other people like it, great. I’m excited.”

She added that there are plenty of Black shows she loves that look nothing like hers. “I think that’s good,” she said. “That’s the way it should be.”

Reasonable Doubt 2

The African American Film Critics Association hosted the screening of Season 4, Episode 9, I Did It My Way, at The Grove, followed by a Q&A with Hunter and stars Emayatzy Corinealdi, Morris Chestnut and Durrell “Tank” Babbs, moderated by Danielle Young. The evening came just days ahead of the Season 4 finale on November 24 and shortly after Hulu renewed the series for a fifth season, following its most-watched season yet.

Hunter’s comments came as she explained how she approaches her characters, flaws and all. “I don’t protect my characters,” she said. “I create them and then put them in situations and see what they’re going to do. I don’t have a judgment.” That includes Eric Cropper, Tank’s charming and dangerous R&B star.

Hunter pointed out that Cropper lost his parents young, raised his brother and fought his way through the music industry. “Probably the people that he’s around are worse than him,” she said, “so he feels like, ‘I’m a good guy.’” She applies the same approach to Jax’s painkiller addiction this season. “As writers in the writers room, we think, how far will people go to get the thing?”

Tank says the role has given him a freedom he’s never had before. He told the crowd that fans often assume he’s ad-libbing Cropper’s most outrageous lines.

“I’m not ad-libbing. This is not me for real,” he said, laughing. “This is on the paper.” He compared working alongside Corinealdi to a new kind of training. On his first day, he said, she was already “running a hundred yards” on take one. “I’ve been doing music for 30, 40 years. I know what it takes,” he said. “But this is a new level for me. It’s been like lifting weights and getting into a different kind of shape.”

The show’s men were a big part of the conversation. Hunter said she wanted Reasonable Doubt to reflect the Black men she knows, including her husband, family and friends.

Reasonable Doubt 1

“I want to see us doing all different types of things,” she said. She noted that Lee, played by McKinley Freeman, is “quiet, strong,” while Eric is “loud, strong,” and Morris Chestnut’s Corey Cash falls “kind of in the middle.” “These are all different types of men, and they have vulnerabilities and flaws and needs, as well as the women do,” she said.

She recalled that when Michael Ealy read the first two scripts for Season 1, he expected to be “the guy on the side” in a female-led show and was surprised by how fully drawn the men were.

Chestnut, who plays Corey this season, said watching Jax spiral has tested his character’s loyalty. “Corey will always respect Jax,” he said. “He’s seeing a side of her that he never anticipated.”

For Corinealdi, Season 4 has revealed a blind spot in Jax’s famous strength. “Jax is the queen of compartmentalizing,” she said. “She packages them nicely and sets them over there.” This season, she said, “it’s all caught up to her. All those boxes are now sitting there open, and she has to deal with them.” She added that seeing “a woman who looks like Jax experience them is the real gift, because that’s not something we get to see often.”

Hunter also spoke about the marriage at the heart of the show, between Jax and Lewis (McKinley Freeman). She sees it less as a story about betrayal than about two people renegotiating their roles 20 years in. “What you’re watching is them having to almost renegotiate their marriage contract,” she said. “It’s nice to see something different and see Black love.”

The Season 4 finale of Reasonable Doubt streams November 24 on Hulu.

Photo Credit: AAFCA